Start free
Comparison Β· seo-substack-vs-patreon

Substack vs Patreon (2026): Fees, Payouts and Who Wins

Substack vs Patreon: both take 10% plus 2.9% + $0.30 per card payment. From 200 fans at $10 a month you keep $1,668 on Substack and $1,681.75 on Patreon.

βš– 3 tools comparedβœ“ Tested 8 Nov 2026 Β· public pricing and help pages, Chrome on Windows

Substack vs Patreon is closer on cost than most people think. Both take 10% from new creators, plus 2.9% + $0.30 per US card payment. Substack also passes on Stripe's 0.7% billing fee. With 200 fans at $10 a month, you keep $1,668 on Substack and $1,681.75 on Patreon. The real choice is format: newsletters or memberships.

Laptop and notebook on a writer's desk, ready for a new post

Photo: Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash

We read Substack's and Patreon's own pricing and help pages on 8 November 2026. We did not create accounts. "Patreon vs Substack" is the same question, so it is answered here too.

Substack vs Patreon: the quick answer

  • You write, and email is the product: Substack. Every post lands in your readers' inboxes.
  • You make video, audio, art or several formats: Patreon. It has tiers, video, podcasts, chats and a shop.
  • Fees alone: almost a tie. Patreon leaves you under 1% more on the same fans.
  • Leaving later: easier on Substack, because paid subscriptions run through your own Stripe account.
At a glance
ToolPriceAds and pop-upsLimitsBest for
SubstackFree to start; 10% of each paid subscription, plus Stripe 2.9% + $0.30 and 0.7% β€”Minimum paid price $5 a month or $30 a year; writing firstWriters whose product is an email newsletter
PatreonFree to start; 10% of income (Standard plan), plus 2.9% + $0.30 per US card paymβ€”Older 5%, 8% and 11% plans closed to new creators since 4 Aug 2025Memberships with video, audio, art or several formats
SellwaresFree plan €0 (3 products); Creator €29 a monthβ€”0% transaction fee on every plan; you handle your own sales taxCourses, memberships, coaching and downloads from your own store
1

Substack

Best for: Writers whose product is an email newsletter
Price
Free to start; 10% of each paid subscription, plus Stripe 2.9% + $0.30 and 0.7%
Limits
Minimum paid price $5 a month or $30 a year; writing first
Good
  • Paid subscriptions run through your own Stripe account
  • Email list export as CSV, free and paid
  • Collects and remits sales tax from 1 Dec 2026
Watch out
  • 0.7% Stripe Billing fee on top
  • List export has no subscriber names
  • iPhone in-app purchases cost 15-30% more
Visit Substack β†’
2

Patreon

Best for: Memberships with video, audio, art or several formats
Price
Free to start; 10% of income (Standard plan), plus 2.9% + $0.30 per US card paym
Limits
Older 5%, 8% and 11% plans closed to new creators since 4 Aug 2025
Good
  • Tiers, video, livestreams, podcasts, chats and a shop
  • Collects most taxes, handles chargebacks and fraud
  • Member email export as CSV
Watch out
  • Fans pay Patreon, not your own Stripe
  • Payout fees: $0.25 direct deposit, 1% PayPal
  • 2.5% currency conversion fee on foreign payments
Visit Patreon β†’
3

Sellwares

Best for: Courses, memberships, coaching and downloads from your own store
Our tool
Price
Free plan €0 (3 products); Creator €29 a month
Limits
0% transaction fee on every plan; you handle your own sales tax
Good
  • 0% transaction fee, free plan included
  • Paid straight to your own Stripe, PayPal, Mollie or Revolut
  • Courses, memberships, communities and email in one store
Watch out
  • No marketplace traffic: you bring the buyers
  • Not a merchant of record: sales tax is yours
  • New, so few reviews yet
Open the tool β†’

Fees compared side by side

SubstackPatreon (new creators)
Free to startYesYes
Platform fee10% of each payment10% of income
Card processing (US)2.9% + $0.302.9% + $0.30
Recurring billing fee0.7% (Stripe Billing)None listed
Payout feeNone listed$0.25 per direct deposit
Lowest price$5 a month, $30 a yearNot stated
Sales taxCollected by Substack from 1 Dec 2026Most collected by Patreon

Substack's cost page lists the 10% fee, Stripe's 2.9% + $0.30 and the 0.7% billing fee. Patreon's pricing page says 10%, plus processing, currency conversion, payout fees and taxes.

Patreon changed plans in 2025. Its creator fees overview, updated 5 November 2026, puts every page published after 4 August 2025 on a 10% Standard plan. The older 5%, 8% and 11% plans are closed to new creators. The old small-payment rate of 5% + $0.10 also applies only to legacy plans now.

What you keep from 200 paying fans

This is the number most comparisons skip. We took 200 fans paying by US card each month, at $5 and at $10. The formula, in words: price, minus the 10% platform fee, minus 2.9% and 30 cents, minus 0.7% on Substack. Patreon then takes $0.25 for one monthly payout.

200 fans at $5SubstackPatreon
Fans pay$1,000.00$1,000.00
Platform fee (10%)$100.00$100.00
Card fee (2.9% + $0.30)$89.00$89.00
Billing fee (0.7%)$7.00$0.00
Payout fee$0.00$0.25
You keep$804.00$810.75
Share kept80.4%81.1%
200 fans at $10SubstackPatreon
Fans pay$2,000.00$2,000.00
Platform fee (10%)$200.00$200.00
Card fee (2.9% + $0.30)$118.00$118.00
Billing fee (0.7%)$14.00$0.00
Payout fee$0.00$0.25
You keep$1,668.00$1,681.75
Share kept83.4%84.1%

Substack vs Patreon money kept from 200 fans per month

Two things stand out. First, the 30-cent card fee hurts small prices. At $5, it alone eats 6% of each payment. Raising your price to $10 lifts your share by 3 points on either platform. Second, the gap between the two is small: $6.75 a month at $5 and $13.75 at $10.

Some costs are left out. Patreon adds 2.5% when a fan pays in another currency. Both platforms lose money to Apple on iPhone in-app purchases. Substack says Apple charges an extra 15-30%. Patreon says Apple's fee is 30% on eligible purchases, though US fans can pay on the web instead. Try your own prices with our Stripe fee calculator.

Substack: best for writers

Substack is a newsletter and publishing platform. Posts go out by email and live on the web. Readers can subscribe free or pay, and the minimum paid price is $5 a month or $30 a year.

On our example, Substack leaves you $804 at $5 and $1,668 at $10. Its biggest plus is ownership. Substack connects through Stripe "connect" accounts and says creators own their payment relationships. You can export your email list as a CSV, with plan type, but not names.

Limits: it centers on writing, and the 0.7% billing fee is passed on. From 1 December 2026, Substack will collect and remit sales tax or VAT itself. Skip it if your main work is video or art.

We cover every Substack cost, including the $50 custom domain, in our Substack pricing breakdown.

Patreon: best for multi-format memberships

Patreon is a membership platform. Its pricing page lists tiers, monthly and annual plans, one-time sales and native video and livestreams. It also lists podcasts, chats and DMs, email newsletters and exportable email lists.

On our example, Patreon leaves you $810.75 at $5 and $1,681.75 at $10. Patreon collects most taxes and handles chargebacks and fraud. You can export member emails as a CSV, filtered by paid, free or canceled.

Limits: fans pay Patreon, not your own Stripe account. Patreon's pages don't describe moving paid memberships to another platform. Payouts cost money: $0.25 by direct deposit, or 1% by PayPal. Skip it if you only want a newsletter.

Patreon vs Substack for writers

For text, Substack is the natural home. Email delivery is the core of the product. Patreon can send email newsletters too, but it spreads across many formats. The Patreon vs Substack fees gap is under 1% of income, so it should not decide this.

If you write and also record a podcast or video, Patreon puts everything under one membership. Either way, build a personal brand that fans can follow from one platform to the next.

What is the downside of each?

Substack: writing first, a $5 minimum price, and the extra 0.7% billing fee. Names don't come with the list export.

Patreon: fans pay Patreon, so the billing relationship is not yours. New creators can no longer get the cheaper 5% or 8% plans. Payouts carry a fee.

Which one should you choose?

  • Newsletter writers, essayists, journalists: Substack.
  • Video creators, podcasters, artists, musicians: Patreon.
  • Writers who want to own payments and leave freely: Substack.
  • Creators selling downloads, courses or coaching next to a membership: look at an all-in-one store.

Where Sellwares fits

If a membership is one product among many, Sellwares puts it in one store with downloads, courses, coaching, email broadcasts and funnels. It charges a 0% transaction fee on every plan, from Free (3 products) to Creator at €29 a month. Buyers pay through your own Stripe, PayPal, Mollie or Revolut, whose fees still apply.

The limits are real. Sellwares is not a merchant of record, so sales tax is yours, unlike on both platforms above. It brings no marketplace traffic and is new, with few reviews. See how to sell digital products, or compare platforms with no transaction fees.

Questions

Why are people leaving Substack for Patreon?

We can't measure who moves. The pages show why it can make sense: Patreon handles video, podcasts and tiers in one membership, and it charges no 0.7% billing fee. For a writer the fee gap is under 1% of income.

Why is everyone leaving Patreon?

We have no data on that. What changed: since 4 August 2025, new Patreon pages pay 10%, and the older 5% and 8% plans are closed to them. Fans also pay Patreon rather than your own Stripe account.

Is Substack or Patreon cheaper?

Patreon, by a little. From 200 fans at $5 a month you keep $810.75 on Patreon and $804 on Substack. At $10 it is $1,681.75 against $1,668.

Is Substack or Patreon better for musicians?

Patreon, for most. Its pricing page lists audio, native video, livestreams, podcast hosting via RSS and a Spotify integration. Substack is built for writing first.

Can I take my subscribers with me if I leave?

Both let you export email addresses as a CSV. On Substack, paid subscriptions run through your own Stripe account. Patreon's pages don't describe moving paid memberships elsewhere.

Sources

  1. Substack Help: How much does Substack cost?
  2. Substack Help: How do I set up a paid publication?
  3. Substack Help: How do I export my email list?
  4. Substack Help: Upcoming changes to tax on Substack
  5. Substack Help: What happens when a subscriber disputes a paid subscription?
  6. Substack Help: Can my subscribers pay on the Substack iOS app?
  7. Patreon pricing
  8. Patreon Help: Creator fees overview
  9. Patreon Help: Exporting your audience's emails
Was this helpful?
Keep reading

Related